|
|
|
|---|
Tuesday, February 2, 2010
The Links
- For the second year running, the World Economic Forum has ranked the Canadian financial system as the soundest in the world. (It's a decidedly lower bar these days, no?)
- Paul Krugman tries to explain why this is the case in his weekend editorial, but in his effort to create a narrative he misses some important points.
- For a more comprehensive look at the issue, Chrystia Freeland does the job well.
Missing from all of these summaries, however, is one minor niggling point: had the US not bailed out some of its major financial institutions, the story in Canada could very well have been very different.
A few thoughts
The lesson of Canada is not one easily grafted on to major banking sectors like those in the US and UK. Underlying all of this prudent banking is a fundamental lack of competition, both domestic and foreign - something that simply would not fly in any city aspiring to be a global financial hub. To a certain extent, the ease with which Canadian financial institutions have access to American markets has given them space to take a more conservative approach. And while the lack of competition may be stable, it's not something the customers of Canadian banks are always the beneficiaries of, either.
I recently read a US Congressional research report attempting to draw lessons from the Canadians for American banking reform efforts. One of the most noticeable contrasts is between Figure 1 and Figure 2 in the report. Compared to the relatively simple and centralized regulatory structure in Canada, the flow chart of the US system is reminiscent of that ridiculous COIN graph. Nevertheless, the report concludes that, essentially, the Canadian system works pretty well in Canada but is heavily context-specific. There are good lessons to be learned, but they are not easily transferable elsewhere. Sorry.
Labels: banks, financial sector reform
Thursday, January 28, 2010
Labels: banks, financial sector reform
Friday, January 22, 2010
The fate of Ben Bernanke's confirmation is getting a lot of play in the US media today. Momentum for his reappointment has slowed considerably over the past few weeks, and he is losing Democratic votes by the day. The Democratic leadership is reportedly 'scrambling' to shore up Bernanke's support, but it's possible that Ben's candidacy is dead in the water. That is remarkable to me.
President Obama's new banking proposals have opened another front in the Bernanke battle, and many, like Simon Johnson, are appropriately calling on Ben to clarify his position on these reforms. There is a growing lack of confidence in Bernanke's conviction to take the fight to the banks, and without picking up that mantle in a public and convincing manner, Bernanke might be done at the Fed.
Stay tuned, this is snowballing fast.
Labels: banks, central banking, financial sector reform
Thursday, January 21, 2010
As Dave covered yesterday, Paul Volcker finally emerged from his (large) broom closet in the White House as the major force behind Obama's new banking sector reforms. To recap, the US president proposed two new reforms to end 'too big to fail' and limit the proprietary trading operations of banks. His proposals will: 1) prohibit banks from owning, sponsoring or investing hedge funds, private equity funds or proprietary trading operations for their own profit, unrelated to servicing their customers- the so-called 'Volcker Rule;' and 2) prevent the further consolidation of the financial industry.
On the surface these reforms mark a dramatic departure from the administration's standing approach to financial sector reform (fairly benign). But before we get ahead of ourselves with excitement, it is important to recognize the considerable obstacles to these proposals ever becoming law, and examine whether what sounds good in theory is actually inadequate in practice. A few thoughts:
-Obviously we are a bit light on the very critical details. For instance, how exactly will the administration prevent further consolidation in the industry, or end 'too big to fail' as we know it? By limiting the size of individual firms through a cap on assets under management or deposits? Or by applying robust anti-trust scrutiny to any future mergers and acquisitions of financial firms? It seems the administration has collapsed two very different and tricky issues into one concept: limiting systemic risk. You can cap a bank's size, and therefore risk to the system, through higher capital adequacy requirements, but this doesn't address the off-balance sheet activities that were the real systemic threat during the crisis. You might reply that the Volcker Rule would largely resolve the off-balance sheet problem, but it seems the administration has very consciously linked the prohibition on these activities to the prevailing bank-holding company model. Remember, all the big investment banks converted into bank-holding companies during the crisis to access Fed funding, which then entailed setting up retail banking, or deposit-taking, operations. Under the Volcker Rule, these banks would now be unable to de-link retail and trading operations, even conceptually, thus prohibiting every major bank from engaging in proprietary trading unrelated to traditional brokerage (think boring mutual funds instead of exotic securities). There goes almost ALL the profit-making activities the banks currently have.
But what if banks like Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley simply converted into a different legal entity once they no longer relied on easy Fed funding for their trading operations? By ditching the small retail operations they have built, they could theoretically return to the old model once they are self-sustainable, thereby bypassing the Volcker Rule all together. This would put banks with huge depository operations like JPMorgan Chase and Bank of America at a competitive disadvantage. Everyone joked before the crisis that Goldman Sachs was the biggest hedge fund in the world: what prevents them from becoming something like an alternative asset management firm? It's customers would in theory possess a higher risk-tolerance and proprietary trading operations could be justified on serving this investor profile. Without formally resurrecting Glass-Steagall, which doesn't appear to be on the table, I am unclear how the administration can put in place a regulatory apparatus that stays two-steps ahead of financial and legal innovation.
-These reforms are an important step in the right direction, but they are also blatantly political, which makes them vulnerable on a number of levels. The administration is claiming that the proposals have been under serious discussion for months, they just needed to be refined and introduced at the appropriate time. This is plausible, as they were proposed on the very day that health care reform 'died.' The administration may have simply been planning a big financial reform push following health care's conclusion, which they expected this month. And surely the posture of bank execs before Congress last week, not to mention record bonus announcements, didn't do themselves or their industry any favors. 'Keep it cool' Obama seems genuinely furious.
But its timing on the heels of the Massachusetts primary in which a Republican candidate won the seat held by Ted Kennedy for four decades smacks of calculated populism. The FT said as much in its editorial. This leaves it subject to political horse-trading, both within Congress and between legislators and the administration. Could it become a bargaining chip in preserving the controversial consumer financial protection agency, Obama's centerpiece reform? Obama could pick off a few Republican supporters for the banking proposals; John McCain has expressed some similar sentiments recently, and the issue taps right into the anti-Wall Street fervor that shows no signs of abating. But he could also lose votes on his side, like Joe Lieberman or the chairman-in-waiting of the Senate Banking Committee Tim Johnson, who is a 'friend' of the financial services industry, to put it diplomatically. If financial reform gets held up until after the mid-terms (when Chris Dodd, current chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, retires) a Johnson chairmanship could pose real problems for the administration.
-Finally, let's say that the reforms get enacted in some form or another. The big winners are then the hedge fund and private equity industries. A lot of people predicted that they would increasingly fill the risk-taking space vacated by the big banks. But with Goldman trading the daylights out of essentially free loans from the Fed, the current status-quo retains plenty of risk-taking in the big institutions. But if prop desks are truly scaled down at these firms, suddenly hedge funds become the major traders in a range of instruments and markets, providing a goldmine to the industry. This raises a whole host of unresolved problems, including systemic risk considerations (remember Long Term Capital Management?). Reform of the hedge fund industry has proven surprisingly difficult in Europe, and limited reforms have thus far been proposed in the US.
So in conclusion, I am left with two basic questions: will the reforms be precise enough to achieve their objectives in an innovative marketplace, and what are the most effective tools in limiting the systemic risk posed by individual firms? I'm eager to see the details of the proposals.
Labels: banks, financial sector reform, Obama
Expect some big financial news out of Washington today: it looks like President Obama is set to publicly support the "Volcker banking plan." Paul Volcker has been pushing this approach for some time (Mervyn King has been doing something similar in the UK), but this is the first time he appears to be getting public support from his boss. Broadly speaking, Volcker's goal is to split the potentially contradictory activities of major banks:"On the one hand, they are commercial banks, taking deposits, making standard loans and managing the nation’s payment system. On the other hand, they trade securities for their own accounts, a hugely profitable endeavor. This proprietary trading, mainly in risky mortgage-backed securities, precipitated the credit crisis in 2008 and the federal bailout..... Under the new approach, commercial banks would no longer be allowed to engage in proprietary trading, using customers’ deposits and borrowed money to carry out these trades."
Simon Johnson provides some cheerleading; Tyler Cowen provides a list of questions to ask yourself when the new plan emerges. Should be fun.
UPDATE: oh my goodness, oh my goodness, oh my goodness! Press release is here.
Labels: banks, regulation
Wednesday, December 23, 2009
- Prospect gives its list of the 25 most influential intellectuals during the financial crisis
- From the above list, Simon Johnson's The Quiet Coup. Not sure how I missed this one back in May, but it's a good read for those looking for a Big Picture view of the financial crisis and its implications.
- Free Exchange discusses the same WaPo review of the Fed that I tackled below; suggests that Fed is better equipped to deal with inflation than regulation: "It's time to learn a lesson here. An institution that missed a brewing crisis of this magnitude is an institution not set up to detect and prevent a brewing crisis of any magnitude. Something else is needed."
- Underwater robots help reveal history
- LOLFed takes stock of TIME magazine's love affair with Ben Bernanke
- Failure by global leaders to tackle global warming leads to new investment opportunities
Labels: banks, central banking, readables, regulation
Wednesday, December 16, 2009
That was Paul Volcker's message to the Future of Finance Initiative, delivered earlier this week. Responding to what he viewed as timid proposals from the private sector on how to go about their business, Volcker proceeded to lay out what he saw as the key priorities. I can't find a useful way to cut this down, so I will quote it as a whole:
Let me just suggest, if I may, the way that I would go about this. I am not alone in this, and in fact I think that I am probably going to win in the end.
First, let us agree that we have a problem with moral hazard. I do not think that there is any perfect answer in dealing with it, but I would suggest that we can approach an answer by recognizing that elements of finance have always been risky and that's certainly true of the commercial-banking system.
I think we need the commercial banking system for more than automatic teller machines. Commercial banks are still at the heart of the system. In a crisis, everybody runs back to the commercial banks. They, after all, run the payment system. We cannot have this global economy without commercial banks operating an efficient payment system globally as well as nationally. They provide a depository outlet for individuals and businesses, and they are still big credit providers for small and medium-size businesses, but they backstop most of the big borrowers as well. The commercial-paper market is totally dependent on the commercial banking market. They are an essential financial institution that has historically been protected. It has been protected on one side and regulated on the other side.
I think that fundamental is going to remain. People are going to think it is important, it is important, it needs regulation and in extremis it needs protection—deposit insurance, lender of last resort and so forth. I think that it is extraneous to that function that they do hedge funds, equity funds and that they trade in commodities and securities, and a lot of other stuff, which is secondary in terms of direct responsibilities for lenders, borrowers, depositors and all the rest.
There is nothing wrong with any of those activities, but let you nonbank people do it and you can provide fluidity in markets and flexibility. If you fail, you're going to fail, and I am not going to help you, and your stockholders are going to be gone, and your creditors will be at risk, and that is the way that it should be.
How can I be so blithe about making that statement? We need a new institutional arrangement which I believe has a lot of support. We need a resolution facility. What can that resolution facility do? If one of you fails and has systemic risk, then it steps in, takes you over and either liquidates or merges you, but it does not save you. That ought to be a kind of iron cross.
In other words: Old Man Volcker is back and he's handing out detentions to the unruly schoolchildren. This is the kind of ballsy speech that only someone with Volcker's authority and experience could pull off.
I find this vision very compelling. There is no obvious reason why "too big to fail" financial institutions should have the competitive advantage of government guarantees while at the same time being free to dive head-first into the riskiest types of financial tools that may or may not be beneficial to the economy. We've just seen what the downside looks like, and it is ugly.
As Simon Johnson explains, this could well be Volcker's moment. It's true that his vision is glossing over the challenging details that would need to be worked out, but so be it. If Volcker can shift the public consensus in his direction, he will have accomplished a great deal.
Labels: banks, financial sector reform, regulation
Tuesday, December 1, 2009
FT Alphaville charts the return of risk as the dust from Dubai settles.
Regular readers will note that I predicted on Friday that Dubai would be an isolated incident and the markets would return to calm this week as the information/communication out of the government improved.
Hand pats own back.
Labels: banks, financial crisis, sovereign debt
Monday, November 30, 2009
When the judging the systemic implications of Dubai World's default, it is helpful to keep everything in context. FP Passport does just that.
Labels: banks, financial crisis
Monday, November 23, 2009
Labels: banks, financial crisis
Thursday, November 5, 2009
One day, we might look back at this article as an ominous sign that all lessons were lost, regulatory reforms insufficient and incentives misaligned following the crunch.
The banking industry looks coo-coo for CoCo bonds. Sophisticated debt instruments are back.
Labels: banks, financial crisis, regulation
Monday, November 2, 2009
-Should the IMF embrace Brazil's imposition of (selective) capital controls? These two think so. Also, FT Alphaville had a good analysis of the decision (I realize we are a bit late on this.)
-Nouriel Roubini takes aim at the 'mother of all carry-trades.'
-Is the democratization of FX trading a good thing? Or is it really just another hustle?
-Speaking of Europe, France had quite an expensive EU presidency last year.
-Is this Obama's 'Vietnam moment?'
-Finally, if Russia considered NATO exercises in its 'near-abroad' hostile, how should NATO interpret the simulated nuking of Poland?
Labels: banks, Currencies, economia, emerging markets, international affairs, Russia
Wednesday, October 14, 2009
Your Wednesday readables are as follows:
- Awesome: The newsmap
- Nutty: The Higgs boson is traveling back in time to sabotage the Large Hadron Collider. I sincerely hope that this does not impact adversely on the sales of the Junior Wizard Supercollider.
- Rant: Careers in investment banking are still popular for recent grads "for the simple reason that... these jobs are f**king awesome."
- Funny: "You must understand what bankers do: we don't make furniture; we don't write novels; we make money."
Wednesday, September 16, 2009
Jut a quick thought I have been tossing around in my head for the past few minutes...where the heck is Paul Volcker?
A giant of policy making, Volcker was brought into the Obama administration in an advisory role, but one that was thought to be an integral part of the US president's financial and economic policy formulation.
Almost ten months later, and he is seemingly MIA, minus the occasional statements that lead you to believe he thinks his boss is doing far too little in addressing the financial system's problems.
Which might just be the explanation for his absence.
Tuesday, September 15, 2009
-Stiglitz thinks the banking system is even more broken today than on the day Lehman died.
-A very good measure of business sentiment is how quickly business leaders are dumping their shares...well, they are really dumping. Bad sign??
-Martin Wolf's lessons to be learnt from Lehman's demise and its aftermath.
-A lot of political hot air has been expended over executive pay in the post-Lehman age, because its easier to grandstand over the compensation of a few top executives, than it is to actually reform the perverse incentives and regulatory failures that led taxpayers to commit such capital to the survival of the financial system.
One source of that hot air, Super Sarko, looks ready to sink a summit over a NON-ISSUE!! Reforming compensation practices is important, but please, there are far greater matters to address in Pittsburgh.
Labels: banks, financial crisis, financial sector reform
Sunday, April 12, 2009
Politique
-Japanese Prime Minister Taro Aso announced a new, Y15,400bn fiscal stimulus package.
-All criminal charges against Jacob Zuma are dropped, clearing the way for the ANC head's election to the presidency later this month.
-An East Asia summit is cancelled as Thailand stands on the brink of "revolution." Elsewhere, tens of thousands of protesters rallied in the Georgian capital of Tbilisi for Saakashvili's resignation.
-An earthquake killed at least 250 people in Italy, leaving near 20,000 others homeless.
Economia
-Wells Fargo stunned Wall Street with a profitable Q1 2009, contributing to the fifth straight weekly gains for US stocks.
-The FT ran an interesting article on Japanese bank Nomura's move towards more "western-style" contracts for employees.
-Underlining the collapse of trade in Asia, Singapore's GDP "probably" shrank for the fourth straight quarter, the deepest recession in the country's history.
The Rest
-In Europe, Barca looked unbeatable in their thrashing of Bayern Munich, a sublime Adebayor goal put Arsenal in the driver's seat and Chealsea stunned Liverpool at Anfield.
-A Reuters piece asks, "Is America's love affair with the 'exurbs' over?"
-Art prices fell 35% in Q1 2009.
Labels: banks, East Asia, financial crisis, Football, international trade, TWTWTW
Wednesday, April 8, 2009
-Is a legal victory for Jacob Zuma a loss for South Africa?
-Cyberspies (China, Russia) have reportedly infiltrated the US electrical grid, reflecting a growing consensus in the intelligence community that cybersecurity will be one of the flashpoints of the 21st century.
-From the serious to the absurd: North Korea has accused the South of poisoning its footballers with "adulterated foodstuff" ahead of South Korea's 1-0 World Cup qualifying victory last week. North Korea also maintains its "satellite" was successfully launched into orbit over the weekend, while back on earth everyone agrees a satellite-less missile now rests on the floor of the Pacific.
-According to Reuters, the US government will delay, if release at all, the results of its "stress tests" on the US banking sector. It reportedly wants to avoid negatively affecting first quarter earnings announcements.
-US Secretary of Defense Bob Gates makes good on his call to overhaul US defense spending, contracting and strategic priorities. He must now contend with the congressional/special interests outrage.
Labels: banks, financial crisis, Football, South Africa
Early in March I wrote a post, only partly in jest, about employment opportunities for recently-fired free-range bankers. But now Bloomberg is reporting that, sure enough, the pink slip recipients of Wall Street and Greenwich are turning to the US federal government for jobs that will put their skills to use: finance professionals have swamped recruiting fairs for agencies such as the FDIC, SEC, and the FBI (for financial crime investigations, I suppose).
I would imagine that the more senior finance executives are also eyeing academia as an alternative source of employment - in fact, for many it would be a return to the type of work they were doing before being lured away to Wall St. by the massive salaries.
And in case there was any doubt that the government needed the human capital, check out a recent podcast of This American Life. In Act Two, they tell the story of what exactly happens when the FDIC deals with a bank failure (something that's happening at the rate of two per week these days): scores of federal agents swoop into the bank's HQ to seize all the money, computers and paperwork, inventory everything, then turn the good bits over to the bank's new owner. All in complete secrecy, and all over the course of a weekend. It's a fascinating listen.
UPDATE: here's a clip from 60 minutes that tells the same story, only with moving pictures! (13 min.) Thanks to George M. for the pointer.
Labels: banks
Friday, April 3, 2009
Politico has published exclusive details of the meeting last week between US President Obama and major financial institution CEOs. Despite the cordial public face put on the meeting, the president reportedly made every possible effort to put these former masters of the universe in their place, including providing the CEOs with a single glass of water, no ice, no refills. How's that for perks!
As the bankers offered various justifications for bonus payments and executive compensation, the president reportedly responded, “Be careful how you make those statements, gentlemen. The public isn’t buying that.” He followed by letting them know exactly where they stood in the current crisis,
"My administration is only thing between you and the pitchforks."
And boom goes the dynamite.
Labels: banks, financial crisis, Obama
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
According to sources in the room, US Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner said the following to a meeting of House Democrats last night:
"We're doing in weeks what countries did in years...It will take some time. It will take some patience. But it will work."
Geithner has come under enormous pressure from investors, commentators, bloggers and just about every other person under the sun not named Barack Obama since taking over at Treasury. The biggest criticism has been his apparent "dithering" and inability to formulate or articulate a clear response to the banking crisis. In the current environment, no one has the luxury of time, and doing too little (fiscal stimulus including) runs the very real risk of plunging a deep recession into a depression.
But, doesn't he have a point?
Labels: banks, fiscal stimulus, Politique
